When selecting a commercial real estate firm, the most important consideration is how well the company understands your goals. The team to suit the needs of your development site will be crafted based on their local market knowledge and expertise.  Garito & Company’s track record of success across all asset types confirms we have the expertise necessary to find value where it may not be readily apparent, and the ability to turn property challenges into opportunities. 

Senior Associate

Cheyenne Matos

Cheyenne began her real estate career as an intern for a real estate development company before joining Garito & Company as an Associate in 2015. She specializes in leasing, site acquisition & buyer/tenant representation.

Since joining Garito & Company, Cheyenne has worked with national clients such as Dunkin’ Donuts, Express Oil, and Montessori School- as well as several local restaurant, retail & medical groups. Her past experience in restaurant management has allowed her to have a unique insight in to how a restaurant operates and thrives, and a deeper understanding of Florida’s retail and tourism markets.

Cheyenne has received a degree from Valencia College in Business Management with a specialization in Real Estate Management, and is a member of the International Council of Shopping Centers (ICSC).


Contact Cheyenne





Timothy Garito

Tim is actively involved in overseeing all aspects of Garito & Company- from brokerage to development. He has compiled an impressive portfolio of tenant transactions over the past 15 years, including prominent clients such as Dollar Tree, Family Dollar, Publix, Winn-Dixie, Ross, Rent-A-Center, Verizon, TCBY, Subway, Radio Shack, LNR, and H&R Block; to name a few. He has also been involved with outparcel sales and development with Dunkin’ Donuts, Murphy USA, Montessori, and Express Oil.  

Contact Timothy




Director of Marketing

Madison Nicholson

Madison began her career in marketing as an intern for a Non-Profit Organization in Evansville, Indiana. She was eventually hired on full time as Marketing Manager for the organization. She is passionate about creating thoughtful and relational copy for emails, social media, and any marketing materials that will move a business forward. Madison has managed multiple different types of social media accounts for a range of businesses and organizations, created and produced several campaign films, and written blogs on influential sites. She relocated to Orlando to serve Garito & Company’s, clients. She is anxious to help each of them get their properties and businesses in front of the right faces.   Contact Madison.





Jameson “Jake” Spengler

Jake graduated from Virginia Tech with a double major in Literature and Creative Writing in 2018. He has previous experience as an Assistant Underwriter for Macduff Underwriters. Jake has his Florida Real Estate License.     Contact Jake.



office::407-777-9660 ext 106

Broker Associate

Dave Baltar

Dave has more than 20 years of experience in commercial real estate valuation specializing in restaurant sites. He is an expert in all aspects of real estate valuation, asset management, dispositions, lease negotiations, common area maintenance issues, and real estate tax.


Office:407-777-9660 ext 107


Broker Associate

Michael Elmore

Michael has been in the commercial real estate and shopping center business for more than 20 years performing leasing, brokerage,  management, construction, and development.  Throughout his career, he has been heavily involved in several Chambers of Commerce and is a former Chamber President as well as Director of Business and Industry.  In addition to working with various shopping center companies, Michael has owned and managed his own commercial real estate and development companies. Michael Elmore is responsible for NE Florida including the Space Coast and the Panhandle.


Office:407-777-9660 ext 105